I was driving down Route One not too long ago, as I do to run most of my weekday errands, when I noticed a sad change. One of the junk shop/antique/flea market stores that I occasionally pop my head into was closed.
For sale. The whole shebang. I’ve mentioned before that there have been a lot of changes lately on this stretch of Route One and the Jamaica Club is one of many properties up for sale or being developed. But, before the place is torn down and forgotten, I stopped and took a few pictures.
I knew there was a story here so when I got home that night, I started to do a little research.
What I know as the Jamaica Club Flea Market got its start as the Pine Meadows Country Club which became the Starlight Club. Bill and Evelyn Eddleton owned and operated it for 50 years as the Jamaica Country Club. I walked over to the fence and spied a pool! And what might be a pool house or a club house or something. It’s hard to tell.
The Eddletons owned the property behind the Club – on Old Telegraph Avenue – and sure enough, there’s a driveway that leads into the property from behind. I didn’t go down it or take pictures (there isn’t much to see but trees) but it encompases more than 8 acres of land. Prime property these days.
The Eddletons died in 2003 within a few months of each other and the Jamaica Club became a bingo parlor and, in 2007, went by Bingo Diversity Thrift. At least in some form or fashion, even if the sign outside didn’t say so. The Eddleton’s son ran the flea market until I guess the lure of closing shop and selling it became too hard to pass up.
Next door and on the property is this gem:
I don’t know if this was part of the Jamaica Club but it’s a building I dearly love. Just out there by itself in the grassy no man’s land.
So, whatever becomes of this property, I’ll post an update. For now, it sits, content to house the ghosts who enjoyed its heyday.